EXHIBIT A: What Is a PI-16 Denial?
Claim does not contain valid authorization
This CARC (Claim Adjustment Reason Code) is one of the standard denial codes used across insurance payers. It belongs to the PI category of claim adjustments.
Get auth letter with correct format. Some payers are picky about auth number format in claims.
EXHIBIT B: Appeal Success Rate
Approximately 65% of properly filed appeals for PI-16 denials are overturned. This compares to the overall appeal overturn rate of 70%+ for well-documented appeals.
The success of your appeal depends heavily on proper documentation and understanding the payer's specific requirements.
EXHIBIT C: How to Appeal This Denial
Following these steps will maximize your chances of overturning this denial:
Request a written explanation from your insurance company detailing why the claim was denied. Ask specifically which documentation they claim is missing or insufficient.
Collect all medical records, test results, physician letters, and clinical evidence that supports the medical necessity of your treatment.
Have your physician write a letter explaining why the treatment was medically necessary and addressing the payer's specific denial reasons.
Submit your appeal within the required timeframe (usually 180 days). Include all documentation and a clear explanation of why the denial should be overturned.
If the appeal is denied, you have the right to an independent external review. Most states require payers to offer this within 30-60 days.
EXHIBIT D: Regulatory Leverage
Depending on your state, you may have additional regulatory leverage:
- Prompt Payment Laws: Many states require insurers to pay or deny claims within 30 days. If they missed this deadline, mention it in your appeal.
- External Review: You have the right to an independent external review if your internal appeal is denied. This is one of the strongest leverage points.
- State Insurance Commissioner: If the payer violates state law or fails to follow proper appeal procedures, file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner.
EXHIBIT E: Frequently Asked Questions
EXHIBIT F: Next Steps
Don't accept a denial as final. With proper documentation and persistence, most PI-16 denials can be overturned.
Start with our free Denial Score tool to understand the win probability for your specific situation, then use our full platform for guided appeal strategies.